The complete message thread persuaded the court that Voss reinstated the Saturday assignment after initially canceling it. His instruction to come in, Brenner’s agreement and her later report that she had finished the order supported the finding that she performed work.
The payroll sheet contained no Saturday hours and recorded the earlier cancellation. The court did not accept that entry as proof that no work occurred, because it failed to account for Voss’s later instruction.
However, a request to arrive at nine did not establish that Brenner actually arrived then. Her 5:06 p.m. completion message was a contemporaneous account deserving weight, but did not establish continuous work throughout the interval or account for breaks.
The deposit confirmation established that no additional $160 had been paid. It did not establish that this amount had been earned. Voss’s inability to offer a separate time record or firsthand account did not shift Brenner’s burden to prove the amount sought.
Applying the recorded rules on proof, clear accounting in pay claims and matching remedies to proven harm, the court concluded that it could not estimate an award. The evidence supported some Saturday work, but not a particular number of compensable hours.