The Tribunal identified the central issue as whether Walsh had lodged a review request by 14 May. It held that the burden rested on Walsh because she was seeking relief from the enforcement process.
The infringement notice was found to be clear and reliable evidence of the deadline. The Tribunal also treated the Unit’s case-management record, as described in its submissions, as the best available record evidence on whether a requet had been received.
Walsh said she had seen a confirmation screen and that an online form had been lodged. The Tribunal accepted that those assertions could indicate an attempt to use the system, but found they did not establih that the requet wa completed and received.
The record did not contain a saved confirmation, email, confirmation number or other objective evidence of completed lodgment. The Tribunal said: “The evidence shows a deadline and a disputed attempt, but not a proven lodgment.”
It rejected the suggestion that a possible technical failure could itself establish the required fact. While such a failure was described as a plausible explanation, the Tribunal held that it remained unproven and that the Unit was not required to demontrate that it ytem had worked perfectly on the relevant day.
The Tribunal said it had considered Walsh’s fairness concerns, but concluded that fairness did not remove the need for proof of the key filing fact. It found no identified additional obtainable evidence likely to cure the evidentiary gap and decided the matter without a further adjournment.
“Reliable records carry more weight than a general recollection.”