The judgment centred on the burden of proof: the person seeking an order must provide evidence supporting the obligation and the amount claimed. Applying the rules set out in the judgment, the court gave greater weight to reliable records than to unsupported accounts and required any award to match the harm proved.
Neri consistently maintained that the parties had agreed to divide April’s electricity bill equally. The court treated that consistency as relevant, but found that her repeated account did not independently verify the agreement’s terms. Her assertion that she possessed proof of an agreement did not itself produce or identify such a record.
The only record presented at the hearing was a screenshot of Bellini’s 12 April message saying he had taken his belongings and would no longer stay at the flat. It supported that limited finding, but said nothing about the bill, the agreement or a condition excluding unusual electricity use after his departure. Repeated presentation of the same screenshot did not amount to separate corroboration.
Bellini’s claimed unusual-use condition was also unproven. However, the court held that his failure to substantiate it did not establish Neri’s version or transfer her burden of proof to him.
The court separately found insufficient evidence for the €90 calculation. Although the parties referred to a €180 bill, no bill was presented to verify its total, coverage period or agreed allocation. The principle that relationship conflict does not erase shared obligations could not supply the missing evidence of this particular commitment.
After repeated opportunities to identify further evidence, none was identified. The court therefore decided the claim on the available record rather than adjourning it.