The central issue was which party had the stronger right to control the ladder. The court placed the burden on Ratih to support her claim with facts or reliable records, rather than treating Deni’s lack of proof as sufficient by itself.
The receipt recorded Ratih’s purchase of an aluminium folding ladder for Rp850,000 three months before the disputed handover. Both parties identified it as the ladder in dispute. The court treated the receipt as proof of the original purchase, but not as proof that Ratih had never subsequently given it away.
Deni’s short screenshot was inconclusive. It showed Ratih saying he could keep the ladder for now because she did not need it that week, followed by his thanks, but omitted the preceding messages. The court recognised that the wording could support competing interpretations when read alone.
The surrounding exchange supplied the missing context. Deni had asked, “Can I return your ladder next week instead? The painting is not finished.” Ratih’s reply followed immediately. The court found that this request acknowledged her ownership and sought an extension of the loan, outweighing Deni’s stated understanding that he could own the ladder.
Return was the remedy supported by the evidence because it restored possession without requiring an unproved valuation. The record did not establish damage, inability to return the ladder or a need for payment instead. The original price did not establish present value, and no evidence supported the additional Rp150,000 claimed for transport and effort.