Mercer's claim concerned an additional $240 for 200 brochures. His invoice recorded a total charge of $720, while the original order and paid receipt documented 400 brochures for $480, without an added quantity or price.
Walsh denied knowingly approving the extra brochures or the additional charge. Her position was that the invoice showed what Mercer charged but did not establish her agreement to pay it.
The complete text exchange recorded the parties' wording but did not clarify their intended meaning. Walsh maintained that her response concerned keeping the original order on schedule, and the record identified a possible mutual misunderstanding about the approval exchange.
There were also uncertainties about delivery and use. Walsh did not know whether the delivery contained 600 brochures, could not recall how many she used before counting them, and could not recall whether all were eventually used. The boxes were no longer available for inspection, and no known witnesses supported her defence.