District Court directs return of $240 deposit deduction in carpet stain dispute
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
Judge Jacob found that Curtis Vance offered little evidence and had limited recollection, while Erin Bell provided evidence and appropriately reported the stain.
Judgment by Jacob · Presiding judge · District Court
Plaintiff: Erin Bell · Defendant: Curtis Vance
The decision
Presiding Judge Jacob of the District Court on October 7, 2026, directed Curtis Vance to return the $240 withheld from Erin Bell’s security deposit for carpet cleaning. Bell sought recovery of that deduction without additional damages, while Vance asked to retain it as reimbursement for cleaning a living-room stain.
