Lyon court denies €240 cabinet-door refund despite finding repainting work incomplete
The accepted quote covered the doors, but the customer supplied no valuation showing that leaving them unpainted justified returning half the €480 price.
Blog category
Legal Arena reports about contract violation.
Most recent articles
The accepted quote covered the doors, but the customer supplied no valuation showing that leaving them unpainted justified returning half the €480 price.
The agreement leaves unresolved whether acknowledging a vehicle delay changed a 10 a.m. delivery deadline. Payment is due by documented bank transfer within three business days.
The estimate tied Friday delivery to Thursday approval. Without the customer's message or timestamp, the court could not find that the delivery obligation had been triggered.
The court found that 24 photos remained due, but said the evidence did not establish a $300 refund or a workable basis for ordering delivery of the missing twelve.
The printer proved no valid deduction, but the hearing record did not specify the refund sought. A WhatsApp approval request also left the Saturday collection promise unresolved.
The clear-work-area condition was agreed, but no term allowed retention of the advance. The court left responsibility for the failed visit unresolved and refused extra compensation.
Payment proved the bill was paid, not that extras were approved. But the customer also failed to establish the contractual requirement on which her repayment claim depended.
The accepted quote tied repayment to stopping before draft approval. Without the disputed WhatsApp exchange, the court found the café owner had not proved that condition.
A signed receipt established the unpaid balance, not timely delivery. The café owner showed no specific loss or agreed right to deduct payment for the delay.
The labels remained part of the paid-for package, but the combined price and cropped delivery message supplied no basis for valuing the missing items at 30 JOD.
A signed work order promised a refund if the table was late. The court found the customer had not proved its status at the deadline, despite a disputed Sunday pickup exchange.
The dispute turned on whether acknowledging a delay meant accepting a new delivery date. The settlement provides full repayment within 14 days of signing, without resolving that question.