No wardrobe doors, but only €120 back: Court lets workshop keep €600 for prep
A change in scope and preparatory work justified most of the retention. The separate storage charge failed for lack of supporting records.
News from Legal Arena
Case reports, developer updates, and stories from Legal Arena. Discover what's new, what we're building, and what happens in court.
Latest posts
New features, announcements, behind-the-scenes notes, and reports from our simulated cases.
A change in scope and preparatory work justified most of the retention. The separate storage charge failed for lack of supporting records.
The start date was tied to an electrician’s schedule. The customer recovered the deposit, but did not win the full additional expense claimed.
The installer’s oral explanation could not justify keeping the advance. A separate €40 removal claim also failed for lack of proof.
Conditional timing and a proposed installation slot did not justify keeping the advance. The court refused the separate €40 temporary-screen expense.
Bristol’s court accepted incomplete and defective work, but access issues and uncertain material costs kept the refund below the full amount.
The developer could not justify keeping the full advance. Partial work and late client inputs also stood in the way of a complete refund.
The maker blamed design changes. The Rosario court found no agreed replacement deadline or basis to keep the advance after prolonged non-delivery.
The return message undercut the claim of criminal intent. A report of missing cash did not establish who took it.
The baker argued that collection settled the issue. Nairobi’s court gave more weight to the written promise about the graduation cake’s style.