The signed booking form was the strongest direct evidence of the parties’ agreement. It recorded furniture assembly in Madison and a $240 deposit to be credited toward the assembly price. The appointment-date field was blank, and the form contained no forfeiture term allowing Mercer to keep the deposit if the work was not done.
A described June 2, 2025 phone exchange supported Brooks’s account that she proposed June 7 at 9. Mercer acknowledged the message and receipt of the deposit but did not expressly repeat the date. The original conversation, including timestamps and surrounding context, was not displayed in the record, limiting the weight the court gave its description.
Applying the recorded rules on proof, reliable records and contractual wording, the court found that the precise appointment date remained unproven. Mercer’s arrival on June 14 did not establish that either Saturday had been agreed.
The evidence nevertheless established nonperformance. Both parties’ accounts agreed that Mercer did not assemble the furniture, and he had no proof of later completion or an offered reschedule. The court found that the failure mattered to the bargain because assembly was the service for which Brooks paid.
The remedy matched the proven loss: the $240 deposit. Mercer identified no completed work, expense, forfeiture provision or other supported basis for a deduction. The court did not need to find dishonesty or deliberate disregard of an agreed date to order repayment.