The WhatsApp exchange was sufficient to establish the agreed method of division. Its wording was clear, and the record identified no challenge to its authenticity, although it had not been independently verified. Repeated copies of the same exchange did not provide additional independent proof.
The messages showed that the €1,200 was an estimate held temporarily, rather than a permanent deduction. Equally, they did not establish an automatic entitlement to €600 before the shared costs were determined.
Applying the recorded rules on proof and remedies, the court held that Anouk had to establish a presently payable amount with specific evidence. Reliable records carried greater weight than unsupported accounts, and any award had to match the amount proved.
No final invoice, payment record, account statement or calculation established whether the electricity costs had consumed the reserve or left a balance. Bram’s acknowledgment that he could not prove the reserve had been properly spent did not prove that money remained or shift Anouk’s burden of proof.
The court declined both a fixed award and an order for an unspecified share of a future balance. No adjournment was available, and the relevant records were not obtainable for the hearing, so it decided the claim on the existing evidence.