The paid invoice established the R950 payment and described the work as repairing a washing-machine leak by replacing the inlet hose. The court found that this description was broader than hose replacement alone, but the invoice did not record testing or guarantee a particular result. It therefore did not establish whether the repair succeeded.
Cele’s account that water appeared underneath the machine the next day was relevant evidence of a direct observation. However, the WhatsApp messages she described were not presented at the hearing, leaving their contents, timing and context unverified. No other evidence connected the later water to defective hose work or a failure of the agreed repair.
Applying the supplied burden-of-proof rule, the court held that Cele, as the party seeking relief, had to establish the failure for which she sought repayment. The supplied consumer-promises rule required specific promises about quality and deliverables to be honoured, but the timing of the water’s appearance alone did not prove non-performance.
The court separately considered the supplied rule allowing it to weigh whether a provider had a fair opportunity to inspect or correct a reported problem. Neither the inspection offer nor the alleged refusal was independently established. That uncertainty could not be used against Cele, but it also did not fill the gap in proof that the repair failed.
The additional claims lacked an identified legal expense, a specific amount or evidence of a separate loss. A general reference to invoices or receipts was insufficient to support compensation under the supplied rules requiring proof and a remedy proportionate to established harm.