The court treated the purchase receipts as clear proof of the transaction and the undisputed 120 GEL price. The central evidentiary question was whether the defect remained after Kapanadze collected the kettle.
The repair slip established that Japaridze had adjusted and checked the seal. It did not record a test result or state that the leaking had stopped. Kapanadze’s signature acknowledged collection, not acceptance of a successful repair.
The messages contained Kapanadze’s prompt, specific report that the kettle still leaked. The court recognised that this was her own account, not an independent test, and did not conclusively establish the kettle’s physical condition. Nevertheless, its timing and specificity carried weight, particularly because Japaridze offered no contrary observation.
Weighing those records together, the court found the continued leak more likely than not proved. This was the threshold it applied to Kapanadze’s burden of supporting her claim with evidence.
Japaridze’s repair effort counted in his favour because he had been given a fair opportunity to correct the problem. It did not, however, establish a successful repair or require Kapanadze to wait indefinitely. Applying only the supplied rules on proof, repair opportunities, consumer promises and proportionate remedies, the court held that refunding the documented price matched the proven harm.