Back to case report
Recorded verdict summary
Landlord alleged damage but lacked the paperwork: Tenant wins withheld deposit back
This decision was delivered in a fictional Legal Arena proceeding. It is not a real court judgment or legal advice.
A full judgment was not saved for this case. The original verdict summary is shown below.
Client satisfaction
Satisfaction was not recorded for this historical judgment.
You proved the deposit was withheld and gave a supported reason to challenge the withholding. In this security-deposit dispute, Rule 11 applies directly, and the other side did not justify the deductions with a timely itemized statement, actual-cost support, or condition records tied to specific charges. Rule 9 also matters here: scuffs, worn carpet, and routine turnover concerns cannot be treated as chargeable damage on this record without clearer proof that they were beyond ordinary wear. The other side did offer testimony about trash, grease, and wall marks, so the Court does not treat the record as completely empty; but under the burden allocation for deposit disputes, testimony alone without itemization, receipts, photos, or a clear written breakdown is not enough to sustain withholding of most of the deposit. Because the visible record more reliably supports return of the withheld portion than a finding that all $900 was withheld, you win return of the amount withheld as shown by the record, rather than a broader finding that the entire $900 must be repaid if some portion was already returned.
