The court ruled for Pollard. The verdict found that she had proved the deposit was withheld and had given a supported reason to challenge the withholding.
The court’s summary emphasized that the landlord did not justify the deductions with a timely itemized statement, actual-cost support, or condition records tied to specific charges. It also noted that scuffs, worn carpet, and routine turnover concerns could not be treated as chargeable damage on this record without clearer proof.
At the same time, the court did not treat the landlord’s testimony as nonexistent. Because Hale did offer testimony about trash, grease, and wall marks, the ruling stopped short of declaring the record completely empty. The result was narrower: Pollard won return of the amount withheld as shown by the record, rather than a finding that the entire $900 had to be repaid.
The court accepted that testimony existed, but found it insufficient to sustain withholding of most of the deposit without records to back it up.
- Winner: Erin Pollard
- Court found the withholding inadequately supported
- Missing itemization and missing actual-cost proof were central
- Relief: return of the withheld portion shown by the record