The court distinguished proof of taking the drill from proof of dishonesty. Under the supplied criminal rules, the Crown had to support each required element with reliable evidence; Reeves was not required to prove permission or his innocence.
A screenshot of Reeves’s message to a colleague confirmed deliberate removal and an intention to return the drill the next morning. The colleague’s response was ambiguous: it neither clearly authorised the borrowing nor rejected the plan. Repeated copies of that screenshot did not amount to independent corroboration.
Nia Barlow, who usually approved equipment loans, testified that she had not approved this removal. However, she could not say whether she had been absent that day, acknowledged that supervisors sometimes handled requests during her absence, and could not exclude approval by a supervisor.
Barlow also could not identify the people in the messages. Her evidence therefore established her own lack of approval, but not that nobody else had authorised the removal or what Reeves believed.
The Crown’s references to Barlow’s signed statement carried no evidentiary weight because the statement was not produced. Its assertion that she had been present that day was likewise not established by her testimony. The court considered an inference of dishonesty possible, but insufficient given the unidentified colleague and unresolved approval process.
“But proof that Callum took the drill is not, by itself, proof that he did so dishonestly,” the court stated.