The court applied the supplied text of Wis. Stat. § 943.20(1)(a), noting that the event date was not recorded and the applicable statutory version could not be verified. Under the rule presented, the State had to prove every required element beyond a reasonable doubt.
The silent shop camera established that Mercer placed the drill in his tote and left. It did not show a permission conversation, concealment or his intent, so the court declined to draw broader conclusions from the footage.
The earlier written exchange supported competing interpretations. Nina indicated that borrowing should be fine if the drill was returned before opening, but also instructed Mercer to check with her before leaving. The court found it unclear whether that check was a condition of permission or a request accompanying an otherwise permitted loan.
Mercer’s account of believing he had permission and planning a next-morning return was relayed through counsel, rather than established through independent documents or admitted witness testimony. The court did not regard it as conclusive, but found it consistent with the written borrowing discussion. His acknowledged failure to check weighed against him without establishing the required criminal state of mind.
Nina’s evening demand showed that she disputed permission. However, the record did not establish that Mercer read it, and his silence was not treated as proof that he received or understood the demand.
The supplied honest-mistake rule allowed an honest misunderstanding to negate a required state of mind. The court also found no evidence establishing that Mercer intended permanent deprivation or knew it was practically certain. Recovery of the drill and the absence of established damage were not, by themselves, the basis for acquittal.