The tribunal applied Rule 1, which required Whitcomb, as the party seeking relief, to support her request with specific facts, records or testimony. It also considered Rule 45, which requires agency decisions to have support in the record.
Whitcomb’s saved portal screenshot recorded a supporting-document upload at 4:56 p.m. on April 14, 2026. It contained no message confirming submission of the completed application. The tribunal found that it established pre-deadline activity, but not timely final submission; presenting the same screenshot repeatedly added no independent proof.
The Office’s evidence had a corresponding limitation. Its 5:12 p.m. entry recorded when the application appeared in the processing queue, while the Office said its system did not record final submission time. The tribunal therefore found that the entry did not independently establish late filing.
Nevertheless, the weakness in the Office’s proof did not automatically entitle Whitcomb to withdrawal of the denial. With neither timely nor late submission established, the tribunal resolved the uncertainty against the party bearing the burden on the request.
The tribunal also found no specific evidence that the screenshot had been altered. It did not need to decide whether the displayed time was authentic because, even if genuine, the screenshot showed only an upload. No adjournment was available under the hearing rules, and neither side identified further obtainable proof of final submission.