The central question was whether Brooks had shown that her payment covered zone 214 at 10:18 a.m., the time recorded in the notice. The judgment placed the burden of establishing grounds for cancellation on Brooks.
The court applied the recorded rules requiring specific supporting facts or records, an assessment of their reliability and consistency, and record support for an administrative decision. It found that Brooks met her burden on the balance of the available record.
Her receipt showed a $3 payment for her vehicle from 10:02 to 11:02 a.m., but did not identify a zone. The separate app session-details screen supplied that connection: it showed the same transaction, vehicle and session time, identified zone 214 and marked the session paid.
The court acknowledged that the screen was party-provided, was not an independent provider record and had not been independently verified. Those limitations reduced its weight but did not remove its specific connection to the receipt.
The notice supported the office’s position that the officer had found no active payment. However, it did not explain why the app showed a paid session for the same vehicle, zone and time. The court found the unexplained entry less persuasive than the receipt and app screen considered together, without assuming that the officer had acted improperly.
The office’s acknowledgment that the screen supported Brooks’s account was not treated as conclusive. The court independently weighed the evidence and found that the fuller record established payment during the cited period.