Back to case report
Original in-game verdict
County Court at Bristol rejects £240 refund claim over wobbling desk
This decision was delivered in a fictional Legal Arena proceeding. It is not a real court judgment or legal advice.
Client satisfaction
Satisfaction was not recorded for this historical judgment.
Background
1. Hannah Pritchard asks for £240 from Oliver Beck in exchange for returning a desk. She says the desk rocked soon after delivery, that she tried turning its feet, and that it remained unstable. Oliver denies that a refund is due. He says the desk was in good condition, that a foot was set too high, and that he offered to visit and adjust it.
2. The parties’ statements are accounts and arguments, not independent records of the desk’s condition. The receipt exhibits are presented documents. They support a sale of a desk for £240 and show that Hannah sought a refund six days later. They do not describe the desk’s condition or establish why it rocked. No photograph, inspection, repair record, or message about the alleged offer is in the record. The parties have had a final opportunity to state their positions and identify further proof; neither identifies further obtainable evidence.
Issues for determination
3. The issues are whether Hannah has proved that the desk had a problem when sold, and whether she has proved that a refund is justified, including in light of the possible chance to adjust or repair it. Under Rule 1, the side asking for relief must support the request with specific facts, records, or testimony. Hannah therefore bears the burden on both issues.
Submissions of the parties
4. Hannah relies on the short interval between purchase and her report, her own observation that the desk rocked, and her attempt to turn the feet. She accepts that the receipt does not prove the cause. She says Oliver’s explanation and claimed offer are unverified, and asks for £240 back if she returns the desk.
5. Oliver says the desk was supplied in perfect condition, that a foot was set too high, and that he offered to visit but Hannah replied by demanding money. He argues that an adjustment should have been tried before a refund. He also accuses Hannah of causing the problem and of seeking money dishonestly. Those accusations are not supported by independent evidence. His concern about his business reputation does not establish the condition of this particular desk.
Evidence and findings
6. Hannah’s account is consistent in its central points: she noticed rocking or wobbling within six days, tried turning the feet, and says the problem continued. The difference between “rocked” and “wobbled” in the parties’ descriptions does not, by itself, show a meaningful contradiction. Her account is relevant evidence of what she says she observed, but it is not corroborated by a photograph, inspection, or other independent proof.
7. The receipt is reliable evidence of the purchase, price, and timing. It does not prove that the desk was faulty when supplied. Rule 2 gives weight to reliable records, but the receipt cannot establish a fact it does not record. The same limitation applies to the repeated receipt exhibits: they support the same purchase facts, not the cause of the wobble.
8. Oliver’s account of an adjustable foot and an offer to visit is also relevant, but it is not independently confirmed. Hannah says there is no further information showing that a visit was arranged or attempted. The record therefore does not establish that she refused a definite appointment, nor does it establish that an adjustment would have fixed the problem. Equally, it does not establish that Oliver inspected or adjusted the desk.
Reasons
9. On the first issue, Hannah has shown that she reported a problem very soon after purchase and has given a direct account of the desk’s behavior. The timing supports her position that the problem was noticed early. But early reporting alone does not establish whether the desk was faulty when sold, whether a foot merely needed adjustment, or whether some later event caused the wobble. Oliver’s assertion that Hannah caused it is suspicion, not proof; I do not find that accusation established. The question, however, is whether Hannah has proved her claim, not whether Oliver has proved his alternative explanation. With the cause and condition at delivery unresolved, Hannah has not met her burden under Rule 1. Rule 37 recognizes that specific promises about quality matter, but no particular promise about this desk’s stability is established in the record.
10. On the second issue, the receipt proves that £240 was paid, and Hannah offers to return the desk. Those facts establish the amount she seeks and the proposed exchange, but they do not by themselves establish entitlement to a refund. Rule 39 makes a fair chance to fix a product problem relevant. It does not require a customer to accept every proposed adjustment, and it does not automatically defeat a refund claim. Here, however, the record does not establish whether a visit was arranged, whether an adjustment was refused, or whether a repair was attempted. That uncertainty is not a finding that Hannah acted unreasonably; it means the evidence does not show why a full refund is the fair remedy for a proven fault. Rule 6 also requires the remedy to match the harm shown. Because the fault and the repair circumstances remain unresolved, Hannah has not proved that a £240 refund is justified.
11. The result does not rest on Oliver’s unsupported claims that Hannah caused the wobble or acted dishonestly. Nor does it treat the receipt as proof of the desk’s condition. It follows from Hannah’s burden and the limits of the available evidence. The record is sufficient to decide the claim; no adjournment is appropriate because no specific further obtainable proof has been identified.
Final order
12. Hannah’s claim for a £240 refund is denied. No payment is ordered from Oliver to Hannah, and no return of the desk is ordered as part of this judgment. The decision does not establish that the desk was fault-free or that Hannah caused the wobble; those matters remain unproven on this record. The amount claimed is £240, the amount awarded is £0, and actual liability under this judgment is £0.
