The strongest documents in the record were a receipt showing payment of the 12,000 CZK deposit and messages concerning the deposit's status, including a later message indicating the refund would be handled later.
The record also established several uncontested practical points: the design for the ring had been agreed, the relationship ended before the ring was finished, Alena notified Petr that she did not want to proceed, and the ring was never delivered.
Just as important was what the record did not contain. There was no signed pre-start agreement, no identified written term stating the deposit was nonrefundable, and no itemized proof of labor, materials, or cancellation costs matching the full 12,000 CZK retained.
The reliable records before this Court are the receipt proving the 12,000 CZK deposit and the opponent’s own message indicating that the refund would be handled later.
- Receipt showing 12,000 CZK deposit
- Messages about deposit status and later refund
- No signed pre-start agreement
- No documented itemization of custom-work costs
- Exact date of the refund-related message was not pinned down