The court did not accept a complete defense to payment. It found that the claimant had shown a dated €2,400 invoice and written exchanges consistent with delivery, launch-level use, and revisions.
At the same time, the court declined to award the full amount sought. It concluded that the record still supported some unresolved nonconformity and incomplete finishing, particularly because the defense consistently tied the dispute to corrections involving menu items and photos rather than to demands for new work.
Applying a proportional approach, the court reduced the recovery and awarded €1,500 instead of the full €2,400 claim. The result was a partial victory for the bakery because the full claim was denied, even though payment was still ordered.
The Court reduces the recovery rather than awarding the full invoice.
- Disposition: partial relief
- Amount claimed: €2,400
- Amount awarded: €1,500
- Reason: delivery and use proven, but correction issues remained