Back to case report
Original in-game verdict
Plovdiv district court denies shop worker's claim for 400 lev in final-week wages
This decision was delivered in a fictional Legal Arena proceeding. It is not a real court judgment or legal advice.
Client satisfaction
Satisfaction was not recorded for this historical judgment.
Background
1. Elena Stoyanova seeks 400 lev from Nikolay Dobrev for one week of work in his shop. The parties agree that Elena earned the 400 lev. They disagree about whether Nikolay paid it in cash when they met at the shop on her last day.
2. The hearing has concluded. The parties have each had an opportunity to explain their positions. Nikolay says he cannot provide the signed receipt or another record showing cash changed hands. Elena has not produced the bank statement or the signed paper she describes. No further obtainable proof has been identified, and the court decides the claim on the record available.
Issues for determination
3. The sole material issue is whether Elena has proved that the agreed 400 lev wage remained unpaid. Elena bears the burden of proving the facts supporting her request for payment, under the supplied Rule 1, “The Claim Needs Proof.” Rule 25, “Pay Claims Need Clear Accounting,” directs attention to what was earned, paid, withheld, and documented. Rule 2, “Reliable Records Beat Vague Stories,” informs the weight given to records and recollections.
Submissions of the parties
4. Elena says she worked for one week and was promised 400 lev. She says Nikolay messaged that the money was ready, and that when they met she signed a document about returning the keys. She says she did not receive cash and later saw no 400-lev payment in her bank account. In her final submission, Elena maintains that the paper concerned only the keys and asks for the full 400 lev.
5. Nikolay agrees that Elena earned 400 lev and that he sent the message. He says he handed her the money in cash and initially relied on a signed cash receipt. He later acknowledged that the receipt is not in the record, that he cannot provide it or another payment record, and that the message proves readiness rather than payment. He asks the court to deny the claim if payment is found, while recognizing that the record does not support reducing the agreed wage if it remains unpaid.
Evidence and findings
6. The parties’ agreement establishes that Elena earned 400 lev. The message, presented as exhibits 2, 4, 6, and 8, states: “Your 400 lev for this week is ready; see me before you leave.” The repeated copies are the same message, not separate proof of payment. It supports that the wage was due and that a meeting to arrange payment was contemplated. Its wording does not say that payment was made.
7. Elena’s submissions provide an attributed account that she signed a keys-return paper and received no cash. Her account is relevant, but the paper itself is not available to confirm its wording or purpose. Elena also refers to a bank statement, but the statement is not in the record. Her description of it may support her account that no bank deposit appeared, but it does not independently establish that fact and would not rule out cash payment.
8. Nikolay’s account that he paid cash is also relevant, but it is not independently confirmed. He admits that the receipt he says Elena signed and any other payment record are unavailable. The court therefore cannot treat the alleged receipt as proof of payment or determine whether it concerned wages or keys. Neither party’s account is conclusively corroborated on the central question of whether cash changed hands.
Reasons
9. The agreed wage and the message establish that 400 lev was owed and ready for payment. They do not establish that Elena received it. The court accepts that the message is genuine for purposes of this decision, but its limited wording cannot carry the defendant’s burden of proving payment; no such burden is assigned to him by the supplied rules. Nor does the absence of a receipt automatically prove that payment did not occur.
10. The court has considered Elena’s direct account that she received no cash and signed only a keys document. That account supports her claim, but the paper she describes is unavailable, and the bank statement she mentions was not produced. The court does not treat those documents as missing evidence that can be assumed to support either side. Their absence leaves the competing accounts unresolved. The court also does not accept Elena’s accusation that Nikolay is lying as proof of nonpayment; the record does not establish that accusation.
11. Nikolay’s account of cash payment is likewise not enough to establish payment as a fact. The message is consistent with arranging payment, but it does not show that the handover occurred. The alleged receipt cannot be weighed as a document because its wording and even its relevant contents are not before the court. The court therefore makes no affirmative finding that Nikolay paid the wage.
12. The decisive point is the burden of proof. Elena asks the court to order payment and must prove that the wage remains unpaid. The evidence establishes the wage obligation but leaves actual payment uncertain. Under Rule 1, uncertainty on a fact Elena must prove means that her claim cannot succeed. Rule 25 reinforces the importance of a clear accounting, but it does not supply a different burden or make the message proof of nonpayment. The court therefore finds the wage claim not proven. This result is not a finding that Nikolay’s cash-payment account has been independently verified; it is a decision that Elena has not proved the basis for the requested order on this record.
Final order
13. Elena Stoyanova’s claim for payment of 400 lev is denied. No payment is ordered. Nikolay Dobrev prevails because Elena has not met her burden of proving that the agreed wage remained unpaid. This order resolves only the claim and evidence presented in this hearing; it does not make a finding that the unavailable receipt recorded a wage payment or that cash was in fact handed over.
