District Court awards partial refund over unfinished edges on shop shelves
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
The signed order called for finished edges, but the carpenter’s estimate also included an optional alignment adjustment that was not part of the agreement.
Judgment by Jędrzej Kimak · Presiding judge · District Court
Plaintiff: Karolina Wrona · Defendant: Paweł Lisek
The decision
The District Court ordered Paweł Lisek to refund Karolina Wrona PLN 1,400 in a dispute over the finishing of six shop shelves. Wrona had sought PLN 2,400 and allowable court costs. Presiding judge Jędrzej Kimak delivered the judgment on 15 November 2026.
The parties disagreed over whether the agreed price included trim on every shelf. The judge found that finished edges formed part of the contract, but rejected the portion of Wrona’s claim relating to a shelf adjustment outside the original order.
