Harare Magistrates Court rejects request for return of workshop sewing machine
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
A thank-you message could support either a gift or temporary safekeeping. The court said the evidence did not establish who had the better right to possess the machine.
The decision
The Harare Magistrates Court has denied Rudo Mlambo's request for an order requiring Tinashe Chikore to return a sewing machine, finding that she had not proved a better right to possess it.
The decision leaves unresolved the question at the heart of the dispute: whether Mlambo left the machine with Chikore temporarily when she moved from a workshop, or told him he could keep it permanently. The court did not declare that he received it as a gift.
