Back to case report
Original in-game verdict
Bristol County Court rejects £180 refund claim over missed shelf installation
This decision was delivered in a fictional Legal Arena proceeding. It is not a real court judgment or legal advice.
Client satisfaction
Satisfaction was not recorded for this historical judgment.
Background
1. Hannah Fenwick brings a contract claim against Daniel Orme concerning a shelf that Daniel was to make and install. Hannah seeks repayment of £180. The record includes a bank transfer dated 2 June 2025, labelled “shelf,” and a written exchange from 1 June in which Daniel said, “I can fit the shelf on Saturday 14th for £180,” and Hannah replied, “Great, let's do that.”
2. The parties’ submissions agree that the shelf had not been installed by 14 June. Hannah says the later messages cannot be provided and that the evidence about what happened afterward is unavailable. Daniel says he offered to do the work on Tuesday and that Hannah did not answer. He also says he was not certain he could do it. He acknowledges that he has no evidence of the Tuesday offer. The record does not establish whether the shelf was installed later, whether Hannah accepted or rejected another appointment, or what happened to the payment after 14 June.
Issues for determination
3. The issues are whether the parties agreed to an appointment on 14 June and whether Hannah has proved an entitlement to repayment of the £180. Hannah, as the party seeking relief, must support her claim with facts or records under Rule 1. The court applies the supplied rules about contract terms, material breach, and proportional remedies.
Submissions of the parties
4. Hannah submits that she paid £180 for a shelf and installation, that Daniel agreed to install it on 14 June, and that the work was not done on that date. She seeks the full payment back. In her final submission, Hannah fairly accepts that the available exchange does not expressly make 14 June an absolute deadline and that she cannot prove whether the shelf was installed afterward.
5. Daniel submits that 14 June was a plan rather than a firm commitment, that Hannah’s response left him unsure, and that he offered Tuesday instead. His final account also says he had not promised with complete certainty that he could do the work. Daniel asks the court not to order a refund. His account of the Tuesday offer is not supported by a message or other record.
Evidence and findings
6. The bank record is reliable evidence that Hannah transferred £180 to Daniel for a shelf. It proves payment, but it does not prove the precise terms of the agreement, whether the shelf was later installed, or the amount of any loss. The repeated copies of the same bank record do not add independent proof.
7. The written exchange is contemporaneous and directly records Daniel proposing Saturday 14 June for the shelf and Hannah accepting. It is stronger evidence of the appointment than either party’s later general description. It establishes that 14 June was an agreed appointment. It does not say that the date was an absolute deadline, that the agreement would end if the work was not done that day, or what remedy would follow a delay. The later messages that Hannah says might have clarified this are unavailable; the court does not treat their alleged contents as proved.
8. The submissions agree that the shelf was not installed by 14 June. That establishes non-performance on the agreed appointment date. Daniel’s assertion that he offered Tuesday is an attributed account, not a produced message or admitted witness testimony. It is not independently verified, and the record does not show whether Hannah accepted or rejected it. Equally, the record does not prove that the shelf was never installed or that the payment was never otherwise accounted for.
Reasons
9. On the first issue, Hannah has proved an agreed appointment for 14 June. Rule 21 directs the court to start with the agreement’s words. The written exchange supports the appointment, but its words do not establish the additional term Hannah would need to show that the date was an absolute deadline carrying an automatic right to cancel and recover all the money. Daniel’s claim that Hannah’s response was confusing is not persuasive as to whether an appointment was made: “Great, let's do that” is a clear acceptance of the proposed Saturday appointment. The finding is therefore limited: an appointment was agreed, but an absolute deadline and its consequences were not proved.
10. On the refund issue, Hannah has proved payment and that the work was not completed by the agreed appointment date. Those facts matter. But Rule 22 says not every failure justifies ending performance; the court must consider whether the failure was important enough to affect the bargain. Rule 6 requires the remedy to match the harm proved. The record does not establish whether the work was completed later, whether another appointment was offered and accepted, or whether the parties treated the agreement as ended. The court cannot fill those gaps by assuming either that Daniel completed the work or that he did not.
11. Daniel’s unsupported Tuesday account does not establish that Hannah refused a reasonable chance to complete the work. It therefore does not defeat Hannah’s claim by itself. But Hannah still bears the burden of proving her entitlement to the particular remedy she requests. The absence of reliable evidence about later performance and the parties’ subsequent dealings means the court cannot find that the entire £180 remained an uncompensated loss. The payment record alone cannot establish that conclusion. Nor does the record provide a supported basis for calculating a lesser refund. The uncertainty is not a reason to blame Hannah; it means the requested remedy has not been proved on the available evidence.
12. The court has considered the parties’ final submissions and the complete record. Neither side has further obtainable proof identified in this hearing, and an adjournment is not available. The remaining uncertainty must therefore be resolved by applying the burden of proof, not by repeating the request for unavailable messages or assuming facts not in evidence.
Final order
13. The court finds that Hannah and Daniel agreed to a Saturday 14 June appointment for the shelf. The court does not find that the date was proved to be an absolute deadline or that missing it automatically entitled Hannah to cancel the agreement.
14. Hannah’s claim for repayment of £180 is denied because she has not proved that a full refund, or any specific lesser amount, is a proportionate remedy for the loss established by this record. No payment is ordered from Daniel to Hannah. This order does not find that Daniel completed the shelf after 14 June; it reflects the limits of the evidence and Hannah’s burden to prove the relief requested.
