The court distinguished the permit’s expired database status from the separate permission contained in the acknowledgment email. The lookup established what the enforcement system recorded, but did not establish that Ben-Ami was prohibited from parking despite the office’s instruction.
The complete email matched the cropped renewal screenshot’s vehicle identifier and receipt time of 09:42. Unlike the screenshot, it contained an express instruction allowing continued parking under the existing resident permit during processing. Those matching details supported the court’s finding that the email was sufficiently reliable.
The court acknowledged an evidentiary limit: although both sides were willing to have the original email inspected on Ben-Ami’s phone, the record did not establish that inspection occurred. That called for caution, but the office did not claim the email was false and offered no separate evidence against it. The finding rested principally on the documentary record, rather than treating Ben-Ami’s account as independently verified testimony.
Applying the recorded Rules 1 and 2, concerning the burden of supporting a claim and the weight of reliable records, the court held that Ben-Ami had established that the interim parking instruction applied to her. Under Rules 45 and 47, concerning record support and consideration of relevant factors, the office could not rely on expired status while ignoring that instruction.
Cancellation was proportionate under Rule 6 because it removed the challenged liability without awarding an additional sum. The office had not shown that the instruction was withdrawn, inapplicable or unreliable.
The judgment stated: “The office’s argument that the email is not final approval is correct but does not answer what the email permitted in the meantime.”