District Court awards $1,800 for ten retained signs in market delivery dispute
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
A buyer kept ten of twelve custom signs after they arrived too late for her market. The judge calculated their contract value and deducted her deposit.
Judgment by Darragh · Presiding judge · District Court
Plaintiff: Nolan Mercer · Defendant: Elise Kwan
The decision
The District Court awarded Nolan Mercer $1,800, plus allowable filing and service fees, in his claim against Elise Kwan over twelve custom-painted signs. Mercer had sought the $2,400 balance of the contract price and allowable court costs.
Presiding Judge Darragh based the award on the ten signs Kwan accepted and retained. The dispute centered on whether a lettering correction had changed the delivery deadline and what Kwan owed for signs that arrived after her market.
