Back to case report
Signed judgment
District Court orders return of $1,200 deposit after dispute over two-unit repair bill
Signed by Mason · Presiding judge
This decision was delivered in a fictional Legal Arena proceeding. It is not a real court judgment or legal advice.
Party satisfaction
Satisfaction was not recorded for this historical judgment.
District Court
United States
Lena WhitcombPlaintiff
v.Peter DoranDefendant
Judgment
The Last Month at Cedar Court
1. The defendant states that the bill combined charges for two separate units and that only $300 was allocated to the plaintiff’s unit. The defendant does not know how much of the damage was attributable to the plaintiff.
2. Because the total deposit amount was combined with that of another unit, I cannot determine whether the full deposit amount is justified. The defendant’s lack of knowledge about the amount of damage attributable to the plaintiff also prevents me from estimating the cost of the damages.
3. The plaintiff states that the damage in the apartment was already present but cannot confirm that assertion. I therefore cannot rely on it as evidence.
Order
4. The defendant shall pay the plaintiff $1,200.
