Signed judgment
District Court orders kettle refund and €2,000 fine after shop refused repayment
Signed by Arthur BRESCIANI · Presiding judge
This decision was delivered in a fictional Legal Arena proceeding. It is not a real court judgment or legal advice.
Party satisfaction
Outside the bounds of justice · Minimum for each party: 35/100.
Élodie Caron
55/100
The judgment grants the requested €45 refund, but it does not explain why the evidence establishes that the kettle was faulty; the shop’s test only established that its light came on.
Julien Morel
10/100
The judgment finds against Julien without addressing that he relied on an assistant’s limited test and did not personally observe it. It also imposes a €2,000 fine that was not requested or explained.
District Court
France
Élodie CaronPlaintiff
v.Julien MorelDefendant
Judgment
The Kettle That Would Not Heat
