The central evidence was a purchase receipt, a photograph taken on the purchase date and Wari’s message after testing the returned kettle. The court distinguished those records from client accounts relayed by counsel, which were not independently verified documents or admitted witness testimony.
The receipt established the K180 price and the agreed return date, but said nothing about the kettle’s condition or any quality promise. The photograph showed an illuminated indicator light. It supported the conclusion that Wari switched the kettle on before sale, but did not establish water temperature, a completed heating cycle or reliable operation.
The court gave weight to Wari’s contemporaneous message recording that the kettle warmed briefly and then stopped at his shop. That supported Kila’s account that the problem was not confined to her home. However, the message did not establish its cause or when it began. Wari’s suggested connection problem remained unverified, and no later test result appeared in the thread.
Under Rule 1, Kila bore the burden of supporting her claim with evidence. Rule 37 required sellers to honour specific quality promises, but Kila could identify none. Applying Rule 2’s emphasis on reliable records, the court found that neither a successful full test before sale nor a defect at sale had been established.
The court also held that Rule 6, requiring a remedy to match proven harm, did not overcome the evidentiary gap. Although K180 was limited to the purchase price, a proportionate remedy still required a proven basis for relief.