The State sought a theft conviction and recovery of the drill, with compensation as an alternative to its return. No detailed prosecution submissions are included in the record.
Mercer denied intending to steal the drill. His position was that Denise had permitted him to borrow it for a shelf project at his Eugene home, and that he understood he could return it after finishing the project.
He maintained that he took the drill openly and neither sold, hid nor loaned it to anyone else. He also denied altering the tool or removing its identifying descriptions, and said it remained accessible at his home.
Mercer acknowledged that he delayed responding to Denise's request for its return. He attributed that delay to embarrassment about keeping the drill too long, while maintaining that a late return did not establish an intent to steal. These are recorded defence positions, not judicial findings.