Back to case report
Original in-game verdict
Erbil civil court denies refund for blender that failed to start at home
This decision was delivered in a fictional Legal Arena proceeding. It is not a real court judgment or legal advice.
Client satisfaction
Satisfaction was not recorded for this historical judgment.
Background
1. Shirin Karim seeks a refund of 85,000 Iraqi dinars from Dara Hamid for a blender. She offers to return the blender in exchange. Dara does not dispute the purchase price or the proposed return, but opposes the refund because the record does not establish that the blender was faulty when sold.
2. The parties have had an opportunity to present their positions and respond to the other side. The final statements add no new evidence. The court decides the claim on the available record; no further proof has been identified as obtainable.
Issues for determination
3. The first issue is whether Shirin has proven that the blender was faulty when sold. Shirin bears the burden of proof under Rule 1, The Claim Needs Proof. The court also considers the reliability and limits of the records under Rule 2, Reliable Records Beat Vague Stories, and the consumer-promise principle in Rule 37, Consumer Promises Count.
4. The second issue is whether a refund upon return of the blender is justified. Shirin bears the burden on that requested relief. Under Rule 6, The Remedy Should Match the Harm, the remedy must be supported by the harm proven. The parties agree on the price and the proposed exchange, but the refund depends on establishing the claimed sale-time fault.
Submissions of the parties
5. Shirin says the blender failed on the first day, about two hours after she returned home. She describes preparing a smoothie, plugging the blender into a kitchen outlet, and getting no sound or movement. She says she checked that outlet with a kettle and tried a second outlet. She relies also on a phone video showing an unsuccessful attempt. She asks for the full 85,000 dinars upon returning the blender.
6. Dara argues that the receipt proves purchase and price, not the blender’s condition at sale. He relies on his message stating, “I switched it on here before you left. Bring it and I will check it,” but acknowledges that it is not an independent test record and does not describe ordinary use. Shirin disputes that a shop test occurred. Dara says he has no further record or direct observation of normal-use performance before she left.
Evidence and findings
7. The receipt and the parties’ consistent positions establish that Shirin paid 85,000 dinars for the blender. The parties also agree that Shirin seeks a refund in exchange for returning it. These matters are established, but neither proves the blender’s condition at sale.
8. Shirin’s account in statement-5 is detailed and gives a short interval between purchase and the reported failure. It describes ordinary household use and steps she says she took to check the power source. That account is relevant and supports her claim. It remains an attributed account in a submission, however, rather than independently verified testimony or a separate record of the outlet checks.
9. Exhibit-5-e3, the phone video, shows the blender not starting during the recorded attempt. The court accepts that it supports the fact of an unsuccessful attempt at home. Its stated limitation is important: it does not independently establish that the outlet worked, and it does not show the cause of the failure or the blender’s condition at the time of sale. Shirin’s statements that the blender was undamaged and that the failure was a manufacturing defect are arguments, not independently established findings on this record.
10. Exhibit-8-e2 is Dara’s message. It supports his account that he said he switched the blender on before Shirin left and offered to check it after her complaint. The message is not an independent test record, its meaning is disputed, and it does not describe performance during ordinary use. The court therefore gives it some weight as evidence of what Dara said, but not as conclusive proof that the blender worked properly when sold.
Reasons
11. The evidence supports that the blender did not start in at least one home attempt and that Shirin reported a failure soon after purchase. Those facts make a sale-time fault plausible. But the question is not only whether the blender later failed; Shirin must prove that it was faulty when sold. The video does not establish the outlet’s condition or the cause, and the account of the outlet checks is not independently verified. The short interval is relevant circumstantial evidence, but, on this record, it does not resolve when or why the failure arose.
12. Dara’s message does not fill that gap. It is disputed and does not establish normal-use performance. The court does not find that Dara proved the blender was sound at sale, nor does it require him to disprove Shirin’s claim. The burden remains with Shirin. Considering the evidence together, the court finds the sale-time fault not proven under Rule 1. Rule 37 does not change that result: the record establishes the price and purchase, but does not establish a specific promise about quality beyond the parties’ dispute over the product’s condition.
13. The court has considered Shirin’s offer to test the blender in court and her final request for a refund and return. A test of its present condition, even if it showed a current failure, would not by itself establish when the fault arose. No test result is in the record. The court does not treat the proposed test as proof that occurred.
14. Because the necessary sale-time fault has not been proven, the refund request cannot be granted. The agreed price and return offer do not independently establish entitlement to payment. The requested exchange would be proportionate if the underlying fault were established, but Rule 6 does not permit a remedy without proof of the basis for it. The court makes no finding that Shirin caused the failure or misused the blender; those matters need not be decided to resolve her burden.
Final order
15. Shirin Karim’s claim for a refund of 85,000 Iraqi dinars is denied because a fault existing at the time of sale has not been proven on the available record.
16. No order is made requiring Shirin to return the blender or requiring Dara Hamid to pay any amount. Neither party is awarded money under this judgment. The order reflects the limits of the evidence, not a finding that the blender worked properly when sold.
