Windhoek Magistrate's Court acquits man accused of taking crate without permission
The court found that Paulus Hamutenya took the crate, but an unavailable image and an ambiguous payday message left permission unresolved.
Blog category
Legal Arena reports about criminal.
Most recent articles
The court found that Paulus Hamutenya took the crate, but an unavailable image and an ambiguous payday message left permission unresolved.
A photo showed a similar bicycle, while a next-morning message arranged the return. Neither proved what Paweł Lis believed when he rode away, but the prosecution had to prove intent.
A camera clip showed Bilal Rafiq reaching toward the counter, but an obstruction hid his hand and the phone. The court said the recording did not establish a taking.
A message about securing cash supported Leah Mercer's account, but did not show where she left the envelope. Her changed police answer raised suspicion without proving theft.
A payment record showed only an HK$18 drink purchase, but the court said it could not establish what Lau knew or whether he heard the cashier call.
A repair ticket and later messages showed why Andrés Solano visited the shop and that he returned the phone, but did not establish what he knew when he picked it up.
A receipt and witness account established that the €24 thermos left the shop unpaid. The court said they did not establish whether its omission at checkout was deliberate.
A receipt showed the sandwich was not charged, and Witness 1 said it was not presented at checkout. The court found neither established what Nolan Price believed.
The court found that Evan Bell took the drill outside, but said the city had not proved why. His account that he intended to return and pay was also unconfirmed.
Elliot Marsh took a boxed drill after asking to borrow a display model. The court said the evidence raised suspicion but did not prove he acted dishonestly.
An initial till search found no drill sale, but a later printout showed an earlier cash sale of the same model. Neither record identified Daniel Mercer as the customer.
The prosecution said the umbrella came from a shop display, but the shopkeeper did not testify. The court also found that Chan's claimed mistake and return were not proved.